Infectious disease physicians: Antibiotic shortages are the new norm
NEW ORLEANS – Antibiotic shortages reported by the Emerging Infections Network (EIN) in 2011 persist in 2016, according to a web-based follow-up survey of infectious disease physicians.
Of 701 network members who responded to the EIN survey in early 2016, 70% reported needing to modify their antimicrobial choice because of a shortage in the past 2 years. They did so by using broader-spectrum agents (75% of respondents), more costly agents (58%), less effective second-line agents (45%), and more toxic agents (37%), Adi Gundlapalli, MD, PhD, reported at an annual scientific meeting on infectious diseases.
In addition, 73% of respondents reported that the shortages affected patient care or outcomes, reported Dr. Gundlapalli of the University of Utah, Salt Lake City.
The percentage of respondents reporting adverse patient outcomes related to shortages increased from 2011 to 2016 (51% vs.73%), he noted at the combined annual meetings of the Infectious Diseases Society of America, the Society of Healthcare Epidemiology of America, the HIV Medicine Association, and the Pediatric Infectious Diseases Society.
The top 10 antimicrobials they reported as being in short supply were piperacillin-tazobactam, ampicillin-sulbactam, meropenem, cefotaxime, cefepime, trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (TMP-SMX), doxycycline, imipenem, acyclovir, and amikacin. TMP-SMX and acyclovir were in short supply at both time points.
The most common ways respondents reported learning about drug shortages were from hospital notification (76%), from a colleague (56%), from a pharmacy that contacted them regarding a prescription for the agent (53%), or from the Food and Drug Administration website or another website on shortages (23%). The most common ways of learning about a shortage changed – from notification after trying to prescribe a drug in 2011, to proactive hospital/system (local) notification in 2016; 71% of respondents said that communications in 2016 were sufficient.
Most respondents (83%) reported that guidelines for dealing with shortages had been developed by an antimicrobial stewardship program (ASP) at their institution.
“This, I think, is one of the highlight results,” said Dr. Gundlapalli, who is also a staff physician at the VA Salt Lake City Health System. “In 2011, we had no specific question or comments received about [ASPs], and here in 2016, 83% of respondents’ institutions had developed guidelines related to drug shortages.”
Respondents also had the opportunity to submit free-text responses, and among the themes that emerged was concern regarding toxicity and adverse outcomes associated with increased use of aminoglycosides because of the shortage of piperacillin-tazobactam. Another – described as a blessing in disguise – was the shortage of meropenem, which led one ASP to “institute restrictions on its use, which have continued,” he said.
“Another theme was ‘simpler agents seem more likely to be in shortage,’ ” Dr. Gundlapalli said, noting ampicillin-sulbactam in 2016 and Pen-G as examples.
“And then, of course, the other theme across the board … was our new asset,” he said, explaining that some respondents commented on the value of ASP pharmacists and programs to help with drug shortage issues.
The overall theme of this follow-up survey, in the context of prior surveys in 2001 and 2011, is that antibiotic shortages are the “new normal – a way of life,” Dr. Gundlapalli said.
“The concerns do persist, and we feel there is further work to be done here,” he said. He specifically noted that there is a need to inform and educate fellows and colleagues in hospitals, increase awareness generally, improve communication strategies, and conduct detailed studies on adverse effects and outcomes.
“And now, since ASPs are very pervasive … maybe it’s time to formalize and delineate the role of ASPs in antimicrobial shortages,” he said.
The problem of antibiotic shortages “harkens back to the day when penicillin was recycled in the urine [of soldiers in World War II] to save this very scarce resource … but that’s a very extreme measure to take,” noted Donald Graham, MD, of the Springfield (Ill.) Clinic, one of the study’s coauthors. “It seems like it’s time for the other federal arm – namely, the Food and Drug Administration – to do something about this.”
Dr. Graham said he believes the problem is in part because of economics, and in part because of “the higher standards that the FDA imposes upon these manufacturing concerns.” These drugs often are low-profit items, and it isn’t always in the financial best interest of a pharmaceutical company to upgrade their facilities.
“But they really have to recognize the importance of having availability of these simple agents,” he said, pleading with any FDA representatives in the audience to “maybe think about some of these very high standards.”
Dr. Gundlapalli reported having no disclosures. Dr. Graham disclosed relationships with Astellas and Theravance Biopharma.
