All Content

A Look at Democratic Presidential Hopefuls’ Healthcare Ideas


Unlike the crowded Republican primary field heading into this year’s presidential election, just three candidates seek the Democratic nomination: former First Lady and former New York Sen. Hillary Clinton, former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley, and U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont.

Although they share numerous ideas, the candidates also differ fundamentally in how they believe the American healthcare system should be run. And they stand in stark contrast to their Republican opponents.

Dr. Blendon

Dr. Blendon

“There really is a philosophical difference between the parties,” says Robert Blendon, professor of health policy and political analysis at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and Harvard Kennedy School of Government. “Republicans really feel that if people themselves controlled more of the financial wherewithal, they would shop more and ask more questions.”

Democrats, however, “tend to believe that when people are ill, they are not in particularly good shape to shop,” Blendon says. Nor are they particularly fit to decide what costs are worth incurring or what procedures they may or may not need, he adds.

Listen to more of our interview with Dr. Blendon.

In general, Democrats believe the healthcare system should provide patients structure to make appropriate choices. They do not support reliance on high-deductible health plans and health savings accounts to lower healthcare costs.

“This is why the outcome of the election will matter,” Blendon says, “because it’s a very different view of what the future should look like.”

In 1993, as First Lady, Clinton undertook a failed but massive healthcare reform effort that would have created a universal healthcare system based on private insurance. Today, she supports the Affordable Care Act and says she will continue to build upon and support it, which includes making changes to the law such as repealing the Cadillac tax and further lowering out-of-pocket healthcare costs for most Americans.

Clinton’s view “is that many people have too large deductibles and copays, and for moderate-income people, it’s really deterring care,” Blendon says. “She’s likely to try to see if they can actually increase the government subsidies so the plans offer a wider range of benefits.”

Bradley Flansbaum, DO, MPH, MHM, hospitalist and SHM Public Policy Committee member, says changes must be made.

“We can’t say the direction we’re moving in is the right direction,” he says. “There is a desperate sense in America that what we have been doing is wrong and we need to change … whether the experiments now lead to a system more Americans would prefer remains to be seen.”

Sanders believes in a much bolder shift in direction. He does not think the Affordable Care Act goes far enough and wants to move to a single-payor system.

“I want to end the international embarrassment of the United States of America being the only major country on Earth that doesn’t guarantee healthcare to all people as a right, not a privilege,” he said at the second Democratic debate on Nov. 14, 2015.

However, his vision is unlikely to come to quick fruition if elected, Blendon says. “There’s not going to be—anywhere in the short term—the votes in the U.S. Congress to move in that direction.

“But it would change the level of discussion.”

O’Malley, on the other hand, wants to expand the ACA and envisions an “all-payor system” like that in Maryland, where the state sets medical costs and caps what hospitals can charge. He has vowed to continue to move away from a fee-for-service healthcare system and has said that reform should “eliminate the profit motive” for hospitals CEOs to keep beds filled.

Dr. Lenchus

Dr. Lenchus

“Regardless of who is elected, I would like to believe they would build off of what already exists,” says Joshua Lenchus, DO, RPh, SFHM, a member of SHM’s Public Policy Committee and a hospitalist at the University of Miami Jackson Memorial Hospital. “The populace doesn’t have the stomach for going through healthcare reform again.”

One of the biggest issues to emerge in the Democratic primaries is drugs: the pricing set by and regulations governing the pharmaceutical industry. Sanders wants to see a higher level of transparency, Clinton wants to require companies receiving federal support to invest in research, and both want to see the skyrocketing costs of prescription drugs reduced dramatically. This includes allowing Medicare to negotiate drug prices and allowing the sale of drugs from other countries that meet FDA standards.

“That resonates with the general public,” Blendon says, “because it’s very hard for people to understand that if we’re free trade in everything, why aren’t we for free trade in pharmaceuticals?”

Dr. Lenchus believes Democrats are going to “double-down” on health reform.

“To ensure the financial underpinnings and some of the partisan concerns are addressed,” he says. “I think with respect to hospitalists, the thing that impacts us the most is how medicine is going to get paid for doing what it does.” TH

Kelly April Tyrrell is a freelance writer in Madison, Wis.

Next Article:

   Comments ()