Browse By Topic and Related Items

Topic Browser

Related Items

Bookmark and Share

Medical Tourism

From: The Hospitalist, October 2010

With nearly 6 million Americans seeking care abroad, hospitalists need to have a working knowledge of the quality and cost of overseas care

by Rajiv N. Thakkar, MD, MBA

David Dupray, a 60-year-old uninsured coffee shop owner from Bar Harbor, Maine, had been having left leg pain on ambulation for four years. His cardiologist recommended stent placement for left iliac artery stenosis. The estimated bill: approximately $35,000.

Unable to afford the procedure, Dupray began searching the Web for affordable medical care overseas. His physician suggested Thailand. Within days, Dupray had an appointment with a cardiologist halfway around the world—at Bumrungrad Hospital in Bangkok, Thailand. Dupray spent two days in the hotel-like hospital, had three stents placed in his leg arteries, and completed a cardiac stress test. The total bill: $18,000.

“I will never go to a hospital in the U.S.,” says Dupray, who represents a growing number of Americans searching for affordable healthcare in the global marketplace.

With rising U.S. healthcare costs and millions of Americans uninsured or underinsured, more American patients are seeking affordable, high-quality medical care abroad—known as “medical tourism.” In 2007, an estimated 750,000 Americans traveled abroad for medical care; the number is expected to increase to 6 million by the end of this year.1 On the flip side, only a little more than 400,000 nonresidents visited the U.S. in 2008 for the latest medical care.1 Globally, the medical tourism industry is estimated to grow into a $21 billion-a-year industry by 2012, with much of the growth expected from Western patients traveling overseas for affordable care.2

“As hospitalists, we have been seeing increasing numbers of patients going overseas for urgent and elective procedures, as it is a general perception the medical treatment overseas is less expensive,” says Joseph Ming Wah Li, MD, SFHM, director of hospital medicine at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston and SHM president-elect.

Physicians in U.S. hospitals encounter potential medical tourists all the time. Some are uninsured or underinsured. Some have insurance carriers that limit or exclude coverage for certain procedures and treatments. Even those with insurance sometimes struggle to pay deductibles, copays, and their costs after insurance has paid its part. Others are uncomfortable with the language barriers and cultural differences of U.S. hospitals and physicians.

Medical tourism also lures patients who are citizens of countries (e.g. Canada, the United Kingdom) that offer universal healthcare, Dr. Li says.3 For example, more expatriates from India and Malaysia are traveling to their native countries for medical care, as they receive affordable and quicker medical care while visiting family.

Hospitalists routinely care for patients requiring essential cardiac or orthopedic surgeries—conditions that are common in the medical tourism trade. With medical tourism growing in scope and popularity, it is essential that hospitalists are prepared to discuss with their patients the pros and cons of traveling for medical care. Hospitalists should be able to:

  • Identify patients who might benefit from medical tourism;
  • Know where and how to look for an accredited overseas facility; and
  • Explain to patients the potential travel risks and complications, including insurance coverage and legal restrictions in destination countries.

A basic understanding of the industry and the issues can help guide your patients through medical decisions and help you care for those who have returned from a medical trip.

Table 1. Average medical costs for select surgeries in the U.S. versus overseas hospitals*
click for large version

Big Menu, Discount Prices

Medical tourism offers a wide range of medical services performed in hospitals on nearly every continent, with a wide range of costs for certain procedures (Table 1, p. 26). Most surgeries cost 50% to 90% less than the average cost of the same surgery at a U.S. hospital. Many in the medical tourism industry say these types of savings have brought once-unaffordable surgery within the reach of most Americans, regardless of insurance status. For example, cardiac bypass surgery on average costs $144,000 in the U.S.; it costs about $8,500 in India.

The reasons the costs are so much less at overseas hospitals, as compared with U.S. costs, are many:

  • Lower wages for providers;
  • Less expensive medical devices and pharmaceutical products;
  • Less involvement by third-party payors; and
  • Lower malpractice premiums.4

For example, the annual liability insurance premium for a surgeon in India is $4,000; the average cost of a New York City surgeon’s liability insurance premium is $100,000.5

Brazil, Costa Rica, and Mexico are attractive destinations for cosmetic and dental surgeries; Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, and India have emerged as hubs for cardiac and orthopedic surgeries (Table 1, above).6

The growth in medical tourism led the Joint Commission in 1999 to launch Joint Commission International (JCI), which ensures that offshore hospitals provide the highest-quality care to international patients (see “Ultra-Affordable Prices and No Decline in Quality of Care,” p. 28). JCI has accredited 120 overseas hospitals that meet these standards.

“Overseas hospitals are always keen in partnering with U.S. hospitals,” Dr. Li says. Collaborations, such as Johns Hopkins International Medical Center’s partnership with International Medical Clinic Singapore, and Partners Harvard Medical International’s affiliation with Wockhardt Hospitals in Mumbai, India, have helped facilitate the accreditation process and alleviate U.S. patient concerns.

Overseas hospitals not only offer greatly discounted rates than insurer-negotiated U.S. prices, but many of the international hospitals also report quality scores equal to or better than the average U.S. hospital’s.7

Figure 1. Global medical tourism hotspots
click for large version

Before You Book a Trip …

How do patients find overseas facilities? It’s as easy as a click of the mouse.

“Our survey shows 75 percent of patients located offshore hospitals through the Internet,” says Renee-Marie Stephano, president of the Medical Tourism Association, a nonprofit group based in West Palm Beach, Fla., that was established in 2007 to promote education, transparency, and communication in the medical tourism community. Patients use overseas hospital websites, international medical coordinators, and medical tourism companies, such as PlanetHospital.com and MedRetreat.com, to find facilities and providers, and to coordinate medical travel.

“Medical tourism is currently unregulated,” Stephano says. “One of our goals is to certify medical tourism facilitators to create the best standard of practice.”

In 2007, the American Medical Association (AMA) published medical tourism guidelines to help healthcare entities engaged in overseas medical care.8 (Download a PDF of the guidelines at www.ama-assn.org/ama1/pub/upload/mm/31/medicaltourism.pdf.) The AMA suggests that:

  • Medical care outside the U.S. should be voluntary, and patients should be informed of their legal rights and recourses before agreeing to travel outside the U.S.;
  • Before traveling, local follow-up care should be arranged to ensure continuity of care;
  • Patients should have access to physician licensing, facility accreditation, and outcomes data for both;
  • Medical record transfers should follow HIPAA guidelines; and
  • Patients should be informed of the potential risks of combining surgical procedures with long flights and vacation activities.
I think the service and quality of care provided at our hospital compares favorably with the very best American hospitals.
—Kenneth Mays, senior director, marketing and business development, Bumrungrad Hospital, Bangkok, Thailand

Patient Concerns

Hospitalists are highly focused on a patient’s quality of care; the same can be said of some overseas hospitals that attract large numbers of medical tourists. “I think the service and quality of care provided at our hospital compares favorably with the very best American hospitals,” says Kenneth Mays, senior director of hospital marketing and business development at Bumrungrad Hospital in Bangkok.

That might be so, but the growth of medical tourism also raises concerns stateside. With sleek websites making it easy for U.S. patients to schedule procedure vacations from their kitchen tables, many U.S. physician and watchdog groups worry about patient safety, privacy, liability, and continuity of care. Although most international hospitals and physicians provide outcomes data, rarely do the benchmarks compare directly with U.S. hospital quality and safety data.

“Quality comparisons are difficult, even within U.S. hospitals, as hospitals use different methodologies to collect data,” says Stephano. “Patients have to rely on JCI accreditation, surgeon experience, volume, and outcomes to decide.”

Recent studies echo the Medical Tourism Association’s claim: Increased cardiac surgery volume at Apollo Hospitals—an 8,500-bed healthcare system with 50 locations throughout India—and Narayana Hospital in Bommasandra, India, has lowered costs, with similar, or even lower, mortality rates compared with the average U.S. hospital.7,9 Other challenges like getting medical records exist even within U.S. hospitals, so emerging platforms like Google Health and Microsoft Vault, where medical records can be uploaded at the touch of a button, “will benefit patients and providers,” Dr. Li says.

The Medical Tourism Association envisions U.S.-based physicians offering follow-up care to medical tourism patients. “Currently, we encourage patients to follow up with their primary-care physician,” Stephano says.

Dr. Li says malpractice is always a concern when traveling overseas; however, he also notes the legal system in the U.S. is strong enough “to handle any medical malpractice.” That said, a patient who experiences a poor medical outcome as the result of overseas treatment might seek legal remedies, but the reality is that malpractice laws are either nonexistent or not well implemented in some destination countries. That makes malpractice claims on overseas procedures a dicey proposition.

“Patients receiving overseas treatment need to realize that they are agreeing to the jurisdiction of the destination country,” Stephano says. Other risks associated with extended travel include exposure to regional infectious diseases and poor infrastructure in the destination country, which could undermine the benefits of medical travel.

Cost-saving benefits have led some U.S. insurance companies to begin integrating overseas medical coverage. For example, Blue Cross Blue Shield of South Carolina offers incentives for patients willing to obtain medical care overseas at JCI-approved hospitals. BCBS then waives deductibles and copays, and several other insurers have launched similar pilot programs.10 “We will see more of these changes,” Stephano says, “to cut costs and remain competitive.”

Immediate Impact

In 2008, U.S. healthcare spending was $2.3 trillion.11 A 2005 Institute of Medicine report suggests that 30% to 40% of current U.S. healthcare expenditure is wasted.12 U.S. lawmakers, employers, hospitals, and consumers are scrambling to find ways to reduce healthcare costs and improve efficiency. Medical tourism seems to benefit a select few Americans, only lowering U.S. healthcare spending by 1% to 2%.12

Medical tourism revenue generated in destination countries currently is limited to the private sector, but that might change soon. Government funding for healthcare initiatives in such countries as India, Brazil, and Thailand is declining. Some entrepreneurial physicians and hospitals are looking to medical tourism to fill the funding gap.

Medical tourism likely will continue to grow; so too will the legal, quality, and insurance protections for patients. Efficient resource utilization might help reduce U.S. healthcare costs, and improved distribution of destination-country resources might help improve infrastructure and access to better healthcare for their own citizens.

With their leadership skills and expertise, hospitalists can play a major role in reducing healthcare costs.

However, what actual reforms healthcare legislation brings to medical tourism remain to be seen. TH

Dr. Thakkar is a hospitalist and assistant professor in the division of hospital medicine at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine in Baltimore.

References

  1. Medical tourism: Consumers in search of value. Deloitte Consulting LLP website. Available at: www.deloitte.com/dtt/cda/doc/content/us%5Fchs%5FMedicalTourismStudy(1).pdf. Accessed Sept. 13, 2010.
  2. Pafford B. The third wave—medical tourism in the 21st century. South Med J. 2009;102(8):810-813.
  3. Kher U. Outsourcing your heart. Available at: http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=1041533291&Fmt=7&clientId=5241&RQT=309&VName=PQD. Accessed Sept. 13, 2010.
  4. Forgione DA, Smith PC. Medical tourism and its impact on the US health care system. J Health Care Finance. 2007;34(1):27-35.
  5. Lancaster J. Surgeries, side trips for “medical tourists.” The Washington Post website. Available at: www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A497432004Oct20.html. Accessed Sept. 13, 2010.
  6. Horowitz MD, Rosensweig JA, Jones CA. Medical tourism: Globaliz-ation of the healthcare marketplace. MedGenMed. 2007;9(4):33.
  7. Milstein A, Smith M. Will the surgical world become flat? Health Aff (Millwood). 2007;26(1):137-141.
  8. New AMA guidelines on medical tourism. AMA website. Available at: www.ama-assn.org/ama1/pub/upload/mm/31/medicaltourism.pdf. Accessed March 26, 2010.
  9. Anand G. The Henry Ford of heart surgery. Wall Street Journal website. Available at: online.wsj.com/article/SB12587589288795811.html.
  10. Einhorn B. Outsourcing the patients. Business Week website. Available at: www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/08_12/b40760367 77780.htm. Accessed Sept. 13, 2010.
  11. . Hartman M, Martin A, Nuccio O, Catlin A, et al. Health spending growth at a historic low in 2008. Health Aff (Millwood). 2010;29(1): 147-155.
  12. Milstein A, Smith M. America’s new refugees—seeking affordable surgery offshore. N Engl J Med. 2006;355(16):1637-1640.

Ultra-Affordable Prices and no decline in quality of care

Kenneth Mays, senior director of hospital marketing and business development at Bumrungrad International Hospital, a JCI-accredited, 538-bed, tertiary-care hospital in Bangkok, Thailand, talks quality, physician training, and patient characteristics with The Hospitalist.

Question: What is the overseas patient distribution seen at Bumrungrad hospitals?

Answer: Thirty percent of our patients, about 300,000 per year, come from overseas. The largest group comes from the Middle East; 10 percent come from the U.S.

Q: Do you hire American-board-certified doctors?

A: All our clinicians are Thai and speak English. About 225 doctors are American board-certified.

Q: What is the insurance status of patients from the U.S.?

A: Most are uninsured. Others may have high deductibles, or their policies do not cover a particular treatment.

Q: What are the three top reasons patients come to your hospital for medical care?

A: First is quality. We provide expert quality care, which may not be available in their home country. Second is cost. We provide quality care, which can cost up to 70% less than a U.S. hospital. Third, faster access for patients waiting for elective procedures in countries like Canada and the United Kingdom.

Q: How do patients come to know about your hospital?

A: Mainly through word of mouth and Internet-searching. In addition, we have been featured in numerous media reports in USA Today and the Wall Street Journal. A small percentage of patients come through intermediate companies [facilitators].

Q: Do you have any contracts with insurance companies in the U.S.?

A: Many insurance companies have had discussions with us, and we have contracts with the major insurers for expatriates. They will not cover intentional travel for medical treatment, but will cover medical care if the policyholder happens to be visiting Thailand. Some U.S. insurance companies are in the early stages of developing plans for international medical care for their employees.

Q: What challenges do patients face when they come for medical care?

A: Patients are mainly concerned about travel, coordination of care, and language, so we have about 120 interpreters.

Q: How would you compare your hospital with a U.S. hospital?

A: Patients say [our hospital] is more like a hotel than a hospital. One of the biggest differences is you know the total cost before you enter the hospital.

Q: How do you measure the quality of patient care?

A: Apart from JCI accreditation, we have our own quality measures like surgical infection rate and patient-satisfaction surveys. However, to compare international hospitals accurately, you have to perform risk adjustment, so recently we joined the International Quality Indicator Project (IQIP), a Maryland-based company that assists healthcare organizations in identifying opportunities for improvement in patient care.—RT


This copy is for your personal, noncommercial use only. No part of this article can be reproduced without the written permission of the publisher. Order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients, or customers by contacting our reprints department at reprints@wiley.com. Copyright © 2009 Society of Hospital Medicine, administered by John Wiley & Sons Inc.

current issue

April 2014

Search

The Hospitalist newsmagazine reports on issues and trends in hospital medicine. The Hospitalist reaches more than 25,000 hospitalists, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, residents, and medical administrators interested in the practice and business of hospital medicine.

Copyright © 2000–2014 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. or related companies. All rights reserved.

ISSN: 1553-085X